|
Greene County, Indiana ~ Friday, September 5, 2008
| Blogs |
|
Every kid needs a spanking or two
Posted Friday, November 30, 2007, at 2:38 PM<< Previous | Read comments | Respond | Email link | Next >>
This week I learned that spanking, as a means of correcting your child, may seem a bit old-fashioned and soon illegal in at least one state.
Massachusetts could become the first state to make it illegal for parents to spank their children. On Thursday at the Massachusetts Statehouse, the hearing for a bill to ban the practice was standing room only. A nurse named Kathleen Wolf actually wrote the bill. She and others see corporal punishment as child abuse. Are you kidding me? I hail from a generation where parents didn't hesitate to "spare the rod" or cart you off to the "woodshed" when it was deemed necessary. There's some biblical backing for that point of view. The Bible tells us: "He who spareth the rod hateth his son: but he that loveth him correcteth him betimes" (Proverbs 13:24). I don't see too much talk about "times outs" and other means of correction included in that statement. Let me say also that while spanking is not illegal in this state, bruising or otherwise injuring a child is. There is a difference. I also believe that spanking should never be administered when a parent is out of control. Parents sometimes need a time out too. Growing up I got spanked, and looking back nearly every time I deserved it. In my house, my Mom was the prosecutor, jury and judge when it came to handing out discipline for her young and sometimes mischievous boy who she was raising as a widowed mother after my Dad passed away when I was just 5 years old. She tried the practice of grounding or taking away certain privileges, but when things got serious and needed immediate correction, spanking was the most effective means of discipline in my house. Was I abused? No, not at all. It didn't take me long to realize that when I broke the rules of our house, disobeyed or was disrespectful that I fully expected to get a whipping. As a general rule, I was required to go out to the backyard and retrieve a small limb -- not too large and not too small -- from a sweet maple tree and bring it to my mother. She would talk briefly about the insurrection for which I was being punished or corrected and then I would get a few whacks either on the legs or the bottom. I remember she always prefaced the whipping by saying something like "this is going to hurt me worse than you" and you know, I never understood that until years later when I was a parent and had to paddle my own children. I remember one particular padding incident that had a long lasting impression when I was a kid who was maybe 12 years old. A friend and I got a hold of a couple of cigarettes and we climbed up into a peach tree in his backyard to experiment with "being cool" and decided to smoke them. Well, about halfway into our smoking adventure my friend's mother walked through the backyard and smelled smoke. She looked up into the tree where smoke from our cigarettes was billowing and immediately yelled at us and told us to quickly get down. As our feet hit the ground, she grabbed both of us sternly by the arms and walked us into her kitchen and commenced to paddle our backsides with a leather belt. After she whacked each of us about a half dozen times, she told me I needed to go home. I lived about a block away and when I got to my front steps, my mother was standing on the front porch and she wasn't smiling. It seems my friend's mother had quickly called her on the telephone and informed her that she had caught my buddy and I smoking. Ouch. I was busted for sure. My mother grabbed me. Told me to go get a "switch" from the maple tree and then she fired up my backside that was already aching from the earlier belt whipping. I can say after that I had a different view of being cool when it came to smoking cigarettes after that. Was I abused that day? No I wasn't. I was taught a lesson in terms I could understand.
Nick is the assistant editor for the Greene County Daily World. He can be reached by telephone at 847-4487 or 1-800-947-4487 or by e-mail at nschneider@gcdailyworld.com Comments Showing most recent comments first [Show in chronological order instead] |
Hot topics Please be respectful with Web comments(36 ~ 3:04 PM, Sep 4)
There's hope for courthouse clock, maybe
Big things at WestGate; thoughts on the VP selection
We're so close but yet so far away
It's not OK to air some issues in public
Mailing list
Enter your email address to join our daily headline mailing list: |
So sorry to let you down, but YES, I was punished as a child, but never wore the brute of bruises. I finished school, went on to college and just happen to work as one of those "so-called lame" social workers. My husband and I never abused our 3 children and thy are all married (with children) and I can safely say, my grandchildren are punished humanely. And I'm not ashamed about talking of child abuse - too many children suffer at the hands of those they love and trust. It's time to put an end to the suffering.
sar.noto, better late than never. It sounds like you were never correctly punished as a child. I never lerned the words "child abuse" until I was watching a Dr. Phil show (or some other lame psychiatrist) on TV. If one needs spanked, tell them of their offense, tell them you love them and apply the correction, firmly. Send them on their way and they will not break the rule again. If they do, then the parent did not correct the child properly.
You should be ashamed for throwing this discussion into the gutter by talking of bruises and child abuse!
Beating a child with a belt leaves bruises - that's child abuse! A little 3 year old girl in Indy was beat to death by her mom and the mom's boyfriend - that murder started with a belt. you all should be ashamed.
A good old fashioned spanking never permanently hurt anyone. What gets me is that the people that say children shouldn't be spanked are the first ones to judge and criticize parents because they can't control their children. I by no means approve of child abuse, but just a good old fashioned spanking is not child abuse. No one should ever just beat a child but there is a big difference between the two things.
People need to back out of other peoples business a little bit. Some people are just not happy if they aren't trying to run or ruin other peoples lives.
I totally agree, there is nothing wrong with giving a deserved spanking for inproper behavior.
Without fear there is no respect. That is why God created a hell. That is why we put "bad" people in prison.
Nosey people want to have control over what everybody else does and touchy feely people do not use logic to make decisions they use emotion.
We need to renew our critical thinking skills and realise that most of this progessive change is not good. Our coutry was at its peak during the 1950's and I believe the baby boomer generation has let us all down. The people who won ww2 and lived through the depression left us a great nation. Now it seems like their spoiled offspring and their grandchildren are trying to tear it down by being involved and making a difference just to feel better about themselves. Why does a person want to make a difference in the greatest country that has ever existed? We should all learn to leave well enough alone and let parents do their job.
Children need more spankings not less. I am outraged that our local school district does not use corporal punishment. Misbehaving children need whacks that hurt their bottoms! If we care about children we will spank them even if mom and grandma feel bad about it.
Most people opposed to corporal punishment work in the social service field. They make money off ill adjusted children and have a vested interest in seeing more people as customers of theirs. They do not want you to raise your kids: the court knows better.
We need to focus on our own lives and take care of yourself. If everyone does this it will all be fine. Your neighbors business is not your own!
I pray that bill does not get passed in Massachusetts. Other liberal states will soon follow! There is absolutely nothing wrong with spanking a child with an open hand on a clothed bottom. It does not cause them pain - it gets their attention and lets them know just who is in charge. This bill is insane! If it passes, it won't be long - I'd say about 8-10 years, before Massachusetts realizes what a HUGE mistake it was! But by then, the damage will already have been done.
You are so right. The problem with most young parents is, they are too afraid to do the right thing and need Dr. Spock's advice on how to raise children.
Perhaps if Dr. Spock would have been corrected with the rod and loved by his parents, Biblically, then his nonsense time-out solution would not have leaked into our public schools.
Without the support of a disciplinary home, our children and grandchildren will always wait until the parent counts to three or ten or whatever foolish limit before they threaten to take away the Game Boy or get a time out.
I like children who obey their parents and raise children who obey their parents.